Nation's Report Card Home

About the Assessment: Participation Rates

National participation

To ensure unbiased samples, NAEP requires that participation rates for original school samples be 70 percent or higher to report national results separately for public and private schools. In instances where participation rates meet the 70 percent criteria but fall below 85 percent, a nonresponse bias analysis is conducted to determine if the responding school sample is not representative of the population, thereby introducing the potential for nonresponse bias.

Before substituting new schools for originally sampled schools that declined to participate, the weighted national school participation rates for the 2009 mathematics assessment were 97 percent for grade 4 (100 percent for public schools and 73 percent for private schools), 97 percent for grade 8 (100 percent for public schools and 72 percent for private schools), and 83 percent for grade 12 (86 percent for public and 52 percent for private). Weighted student participation rates were 95 percent at grade 4, 93 percent at grade 8, and 80 percent at grade 12. The nonresponse bias analysis for private schools at grades 4 and 8 showed that substitution and weight adjustments reduced the potential bias.  At grade 12, the school participation rate for private schools fell below the standard for reporting.

Because the grade 12 weighted student participation rate in public schools was below 85 percent (79 percent), a student nonresponse bias analysis was conducted. That analysis showed that the responding student sample differed from the original student sample with respect to race, relative age, and student disability status. After adjusting the sampling weights to account for student nonresponse, the remaining bias was small, with the nonresponse adjusted estimates for the three identified variables differing from the unadjusted estimates by plus or minus 0.1 percentage points.

State and district participation

Standards established by the National Assessment Governing Board require that school participation rates for the original state samples need to be at least 85 percent for results to be reported. In 2009, all 52 states and jurisdictions, along with all 18 districts participating in the mathematics assessment at grades 4 and 8 met this participation rate requirement. Because the weighted school participation rate in Illinois was 84.5 percent, a school nonresponse bias analysis was conducted for the grade 12 public school sample in that state. That analysis showed that the potential nonresponse bias was effectively reduced by including substitute schools and adjusting the sampling weights to account for school nonresponse. The school participation rates for the remaining 10 states all met the required standard with weighted participation rates ranging from 92 to 100 percent.

Student nonresponse bias analyses were conducted at grade 12 for Connecticut, Florida, Illinois, Iowa, Massachusetts, New Hampshire, New Jersey, South Dakota, and West Virginia, where the student response rate fell below 85 percent. Across these nine states, after nonresponse adjustments, the percentage difference between nonresponse adjusted sample and eligible student sample was 1.3 percent or less. Based on the student characteristics available, there does not appear to be evidence of substantial bias resulting from student nonresponse.

The tables below provide participation rates before substitution.

Learn more about the sampling design.

National and State
Public school and student participation rates in NAEP mathematics at grade 4, by urban district: 2009
  School participation Student participation
District Student-
Number of
Number of
Atlanta  100 60 96 1,200
Austin 100 70 95 1,500
Baltimore City 100 80 94 1,100
Boston 100 80 95 1,100
Charlotte 100 60 94 1,500
Chicago 100 110 95 1,900
Cleveland  100 80 90 900
Detroit 100 60 91 900
District of Columbia  (DCPS) 100 80 95 1,300
Fresno  100 50 95 1,400
Houston 100 90 95 2,200
Jefferson City (KY)   100 70 94 1,400
Los Angeles 100 80 95 2,200
Miami-Dade  100 90 95 2,200
Milwaukee 100 90 94 1,300
New York City 100 90 94 2,200
Philadelphia 100 70 94 1,300
San Diego   100 60 95 1,300
NOTE: The number of schools is rounded to the nearest ten. The number of students is rounded to the nearest hundred. DCPS = District of Columbia Public Schools.
SOURCE: U.S. Department of Education, Institute of Education Sciences, National Center for Education Statistics, National Assessment of Educational Progress (NAEP), 2009 Mathematics Assessment.