Percentages at or above each achievement level for grade 4 mathematics, by race/ethnicity used to report trends, school-reported and jurisdiction: 2011, 2009, 2007, 2005, and 2003
YearJurisdictionWhiteBlackHispanicAsian/Pacific IslanderAmerican Indian/Alaska NativeTwo or more races
below Basicat or above Basicat or above Proficientat Advancedbelow Basicat or above Basicat or above Proficientat Advancedbelow Basicat or above Basicat or above Proficientat Advancedbelow Basicat or above Basicat or above Proficientat Advancedbelow Basicat or above Basicat or above Proficientat Advancedbelow Basicat or above Basicat or above Proficientat Advanced
— Not available.
# Rounds to zero.
‡ Reporting standards not met.
NOTE: Black includes African American, Hispanic includes Latino, and Pacific Islander includes Native Hawaiian. Race categories exclude Hispanic origin. Prior to 2011, students in the "two or more races" category were categorized as "unclassified." The 2017 assessed sample for Dallas in grade 4 reading was not representative of the target population for two major reporting groups: Hispanic and English language learner students. Assessed samples in Dallas for other grades and subjects in 2017 were unaffected. DCPS = District of Columbia Public Schools. Detail may not sum to totals because of rounding. Some apparent differences between estimates may not be statistically significant. Analyze results with NAEP Data Explorer.
SOURCE: U.S. Department of Education, Institute of Education Sciences, National Center for Education Statistics, National Assessment of Educational Progress (NAEP), 2003, 2005, 2007, 2009, and 2011 Mathematics Assessments.
2011National public99152934661712872242991622032682421585439
2011 Large city99155123763161297123214865215346630414864610
2011 Albuquerque892611330702423466255
2011 Atlanta298842842581112971272
2011 Austin199802322782221882323
2011 Baltimore City1486448346614#
2011 Boston7936316247621120802625956919
2011 Charlotte3977621208024113873837936518
2011 Chicago1486529455513#356517113875011
2011 Cleveland247628154466#425811#
2011 Dallas3976712307013#1981261
2011 Detroit69312#47537#
2011 District of Columbia (DCPS)199853350501213763222
2011 Fresno20803955149112495110#3664161
2011 Hillsborough County (FL)5955911307020115853739915315
2011 Houston4966817257520#18823023977721
2011 Jefferson County (KY)13874163862131178336413876717
2011 Los Angeles14864574753111415915110905513
2011 Miami-Dade496601033671711981354
2011 Milwaukee198138453476#40601412971243
2011 New York City138750133169191307022212885715
2011 Philadelphia16844364060121366416114865816
2011 San Diego595661835651722872242138753816845713
2009National public109050837631513070211991611832682321486416
2009 Large city10905512415914131692111090581734662621783406
2009 Albuquerque
2009 Atlanta298792443571113466161
2009 Austin3977416297113#2179251
2009 Baltimore City1684346396110#
2009 Boston8925211227823123772416946526
2009 Charlotte39772212575241188227299163208924912
2009 Chicago178344752489#30701814966015
2009 Cleveland277317156445#445613#
2009 Dallas
2009 Detroit71293#61395#
2009 District of Columbia (DCPS)199813351499#3169252
2009 Fresno21793645446121455510#4159161
2009 Hillsborough County (FL)
2009 Houston1997113287217#17832812987822
2009 Jefferson County (KY)168444846541113565231
2009 Los Angeles1387459594110142581411387509
2009 Miami-Dade496618366412#1684353
2009 Milwaukee148642654467#29711612377281
2009 New York City6945812307021226742437936817
2009 Philadelphia2080379465410#40601511387406
2009 San Diego6946214366415#346619214865010
2007National public99151837631513169221991591628722631684396
2007 Large city10905410425813134662111189571528722741783385
2007 Albuquerque
2007 Atlanta1998122455511#4060164
2007 Austin2987618326817222782621998327
2007 Baltimore City
2007 Boston793529297118124762329916117
2007 Charlotte2987217257523120802622987521
2007 Chicago168447852488#4060161892538
2007 Cleveland208025255455#475310#
2007 Dallas
2007 Detroit
2007 District of Columbia (DCPS)991732755458#4357191
2007 Fresno
2007 Hillsborough County (FL)
2007 Houston496762231691611882251#1007522
2007 Jefferson County (KY)
2007 Los Angeles109050846541314555141892495
2007 Miami-Dade
2007 Milwaukee
2007 New York City991538287220126742627936518
2007 Philadelphia
2007 San Diego10905913356521136642111288509
2005National public1189477406013133671911189541431692221882385
2005 Large city1288509455511136641711387491227732752278352
2005 Albuquerque
2005 Atlanta496722249519#
2005 Austin199751726741822080272
2005 Baltimore City
2005 Boston1288436356513#307014#2986512
2005 Charlotte3977019267421119812714966214
2005 Chicago128843659416#4555131
2005 Cleveland198125148528#326818#
2005 Dallas
2005 Detroit
2005 District of Columbia (DCPS)199782359415#4951111
2005 Fresno
2005 Hillsborough County (FL)
2005 Houston3977316336714#2278231
2005 Jefferson County (KY)
2005 Los Angeles1387491058429#47531311288459
2005 Miami-Dade
2005 Milwaukee
2005 New York City13874663763141307018#8926015
2005 Philadelphia
2005 San Diego694509406015137631611387469
2003National public1387425465410#38621511387481035651812080323
2003 Large city148642653478#415913#1486471028722632773302
2003 Albuquerque
2003 Atlanta1189702055457#
2003 Austin
2003 Baltimore City
2003 Boston237732545556#49517#1387434
2003 Charlotte4966612277320120802611090609
2003 Chicago188231261394#4555101
2003 Cleveland208027256445#425814#
2003 Dallas
2003 Detroit
2003 District of Columbia (DCPS)397712167334#61397#
2003 Fresno
2003 Hillsborough County (FL)
2003 Houston496637386212#3070151
2003 Jefferson County (KY)
2003 Los Angeles178344458426#54467#1486384
2003 Miami-Dade
2003 Milwaukee
2003 New York City1288427425812#406013#1189479
2003 Philadelphia
2003 San Diego138741646548#47539#1684324