Percentages at or above each achievement level for grade 4 mathematics, by status as English learner, 2 categories and jurisdiction: 2011, 2009, 2007, 2005, and 2003
YearJurisdictionELLNot ELL
below Basicat or above Basicat or above Proficientat Advancedbelow Basicat or above Basicat or above Proficientat Advanced
— Not available.
# Rounds to zero.
‡ Reporting standards not met.
NOTE: The 2017 assessed sample for Dallas in grade 4 reading was not representative of the target population for two major reporting groups: Hispanic and English language learner students. Assessed samples in Dallas for other grades and subjects in 2017 were unaffected. DCPS = District of Columbia Public Schools. Detail may not sum to totals because of rounding. Some apparent differences between estimates may not be statistically significant. Analyze results with NAEP Data Explorer.
SOURCE: U.S. Department of Education, Institute of Education Sciences, National Center for Education Statistics, National Assessment of Educational Progress (NAEP), 2003, 2005, 2007, 2009, and 2011 Mathematics Assessments.
2011National public42581411585437
2011 Large city42581412179356
2011 Albuquerque54465#1882407
2011 Atlanta3466255
2011 Austin22782319915713
2011 Baltimore City3268171
2011 Boston23772211684387
2011 Charlotte257521110905110
2011 Chicago5644813268232
2011 Cleveland54468#465411#
2011 Dallas22782111981292
2011 Detroit49516#68323#
2011 District of Columbia (DCPS)544612#4060246
2011 Fresno66343#3565202
2011 Hillsborough County (FL)277319#1189488
2011 Houston22782311585385
2011 Jefferson County (KY)2278325
2011 Los Angeles64363#2377283
2011 Miami-Dade50507#1684384
2011 Milwaukee47538#4159161
2011 New York City53478#1981377
2011 Philadelphia61398#3268212
2011 San Diego386215111895311
2009National public43571211684416
2009 Large city455511#2476336
2009 Albuquerque
2009 Atlanta3664224
2009 Austin26742011288468
2009 Baltimore City3664131
2009 Boston35651311684345
2009 Charlotte257517113874711
2009 Chicago5644713664192
2009 Cleveland49519#
2009 Dallas
2009 Detroit69313#
2009 District of Columbia (DCPS)44561514357194
2009 Fresno59413#3565191
2009 Hillsborough County (FL)
2009 Houston22782211684354
2009 Jefferson County (KY)2773326
2009 Los Angeles60404#2476293
2009 Miami-Dade45551311783344
2009 Milwaukee33671514258151
2009 New York City415913#1783397
2009 Philadelphia57431013862172
2009 San Diego435713#11894910
2007National public44561311684426
2007 Large city48521212575325
2007 Albuquerque
2007 Atlanta3862213
2007 Austin30701711387499
2007 Baltimore City
2007 Boston30702322080294
2007 Charlotte23772111486479
2007 Chicago56446#3961192
2007 Cleveland59416#465410#
2007 Dallas
2007 Detroit
2007 District of Columbia (DCPS)5842915050143
2007 Fresno
2007 Hillsborough County (FL)
2007 Houston23771911981334
2007 Jefferson County (KY)
2007 Los Angeles57437#2575303
2007 Miami-Dade
2007 Milwaukee
2007 New York City44561111783386
2007 Philadelphia
2007 San Diego42581511585488
2005National public46541111882385
2005 Large city505010#2872284
2005 Albuquerque
2005 Atlanta4357173
2005 Austin32681411090489
2005 Baltimore City
2005 Boston396114#2674232
2005 Charlotte247616214864710
2005 Chicago72283#4456151
2005 Cleveland406013#
2005 Dallas
2005 Detroit
2005 District of Columbia (DCPS)6436715545101
2005 Fresno
2005 Hillsborough County (FL)
2005 Houston277316#2080324
2005 Jefferson County (KY)
2005 Los Angeles55458#2872304
2005 Miami-Dade
2005 Milwaukee
2005 New York City52485#2476283
2005 Philadelphia
2005 San Diego45551111684396
2003National public51499#2179344
2003 Large city55457#3367243
2003 Albuquerque
2003 Atlanta5050132
2003 Austin
2003 Baltimore City
2003 Boston59415#3862141
2003 Charlotte33671721585436
2003 Chicago67333#4654111
2003 Cleveland495110#
2003 Dallas
2003 Detroit
2003 District of Columbia (DCPS)72283#633771
2003 Fresno
2003 Hillsborough County (FL)
2003 Houston396110#2674222
2003 Jefferson County (KY)
2003 Los Angeles61394#3268232
2003 Miami-Dade
2003 Milwaukee
2003 New York City66347#3070223
2003 Philadelphia
2003 San Diego55455#2377273