Percentages at or above each achievement level for grade 4 mathematics, by National School Lunch Program eligibility, 3 categories and jurisdiction: 2009, 2007, 2005, and 2003
Year
Jurisdiction
Eligible
Not eligible
Information not available
below Basic
Standard Error
at or above Basic
Standard Error
at or above Proficient
Standard Error
at Advanced
Standard Error
below Basic
Standard Error
at or above Basic
Standard Error
at or above Proficient
Standard Error
at Advanced
Standard Error
below Basic
Standard Error
at or above Basic
Standard Error
at or above Proficient
Standard Error
at Advanced
Standard Error
— Not available.
† Not applicable.
# Rounds to zero.
‡ Reporting standards not met.
NOTE: DCPS = District of Columbia Public Schools. Detail may not sum to totals because of rounding. Some apparent differences between estimates may not be
statistically significant
. Analyze
results
with NAEP Data Explorer.
SOURCE: U.S. Department of Education, Institute of Education Sciences, National Center for Education Statistics, National Assessment of Educational Progress (NAEP), 2003, 2005, 2007, and 2009 Mathematics Assessments.
2009
National public
29
(0.4)
71
(0.4)
22
(0.3)
1
(0.1)
9
(0.2)
91
(0.2)
54
(0.4)
10
(0.3)
22
(5.9)
78
(5.9)
42
(7.2)
7
(2.2)
2009
Large city
34
(0.5)
66
(0.5)
20
(0.6)
2
(0.2)
13
(0.9)
87
(0.9)
51
(1.6)
12
(1.0)
23
(5.4)
77
(5.4)
44
(6.2)
7
(3.1)
2009
Atlanta
46
(2.1)
54
(2.1)
9
(1.0)
#
(†)
8
(2.0)
92
(2.0)
59
(2.8)
15
(2.4)
‡
(†)
‡
(†)
‡
(†)
‡
(†)
2009
Austin
24
(2.4)
76
(2.4)
22
(1.7)
1
(0.4)
4
(1.2)
96
(1.2)
68
(2.2)
16
(2.2)
‡
(†)
‡
(†)
‡
(†)
‡
(†)
2009
Baltimore City
38
(2.1)
62
(2.1)
9
(1.3)
#
(†)
25
(3.7)
75
(3.7)
30
(4.0)
3
(1.6)
‡
(†)
‡
(†)
‡
(†)
‡
(†)
2009
Boston
22
(1.6)
78
(1.6)
25
(1.6)
2
(0.6)
9
(2.1)
91
(2.1)
51
(4.7)
12
(2.4)
‡
(†)
‡
(†)
‡
(†)
‡
(†)
2009
Charlotte
23
(1.5)
77
(1.5)
24
(1.9)
2
(0.6)
6
(1.3)
94
(1.3)
63
(2.4)
17
(2.1)
‡
(†)
‡
(†)
‡
(†)
‡
(†)
2009
Chicago
41
(1.8)
59
(1.8)
14
(1.1)
1
(0.3)
16
(3.7)
84
(3.7)
46
(4.6)
9
(2.3)
‡
(†)
‡
(†)
‡
(†)
‡
(†)
2009
Cleveland
49
(2.2)
51
(2.2)
8
(1.3)
#
(0.3)
‡
(†)
‡
(†)
‡
(†)
‡
(†)
‡
(†)
‡
(†)
‡
(†)
‡
(†)
2009
Detroit
72
(2.3)
28
(2.3)
2
(0.7)
#
(†)
59
(5.5)
41
(5.5)
6
(3.0)
#
(†)
‡
(†)
‡
(†)
‡
(†)
‡
(†)
2009
District of Columbia (DCPS)
53
(1.8)
47
(1.8)
8
(0.9)
#
(†)
17
(2.2)
83
(2.2)
46
(2.5)
14
(1.5)
‡
(†)
‡
(†)
‡
(†)
‡
(†)
2009
Fresno
46
(2.3)
54
(2.3)
11
(1.3)
#
(0.2)
12
(4.6)
88
(4.6)
42
(4.6)
6
(3.4)
‡
(†)
‡
(†)
‡
(†)
‡
(†)
2009
Houston
20
(1.8)
80
(1.8)
24
(1.9)
1
(0.4)
8
(2.5)
92
(2.5)
58
(4.0)
10
(2.6)
‡
(†)
‡
(†)
‡
(†)
‡
(†)
2009
Jefferson County (KY)
40
(2.2)
60
(2.2)
16
(1.7)
1
(0.5)
10
(1.6)
90
(1.6)
54
(2.7)
13
(1.9)
‡
(†)
‡
(†)
‡
(†)
‡
(†)
2009
Los Angeles
43
(1.8)
57
(1.8)
15
(1.3)
1
(0.3)
14
(2.5)
86
(2.5)
48
(7.8)
9
(3.6)
22
(5.3)
78
(5.3)
35
(7.9)
5
(2.7)
2009
Miami-Dade
25
(2.1)
75
(2.1)
23
(1.6)
1
(0.4)
8
(1.2)
92
(1.2)
54
(2.6)
8
(1.4)
‡
(†)
‡
(†)
‡
(†)
‡
(†)
2009
Milwaukee
46
(2.6)
54
(2.6)
11
(1.3)
1
(0.3)
23
(3.4)
77
(3.4)
31
(4.7)
4
(1.3)
‡
(†)
‡
(†)
‡
(†)
‡
(†)
2009
New York City
23
(1.2)
77
(1.2)
32
(1.8)
4
(0.6)
9
(2.7)
91
(2.7)
57
(3.8)
18
(3.4)
‡
(†)
‡
(†)
‡
(†)
‡
(†)
2009
Philadelphia
42
(2.1)
58
(2.1)
13
(1.7)
1
(0.2)
17
(4.0)
83
(4.0)
38
(7.0)
10
(3.6)
‡
(†)
‡
(†)
‡
(†)
‡
(†)
2009
San Diego
34
(2.9)
66
(2.9)
19
(1.8)
2
(0.5)
6
(1.5)
94
(1.5)
62
(3.2)
14
(2.3)
‡
(†)
‡
(†)
‡
(†)
‡
(†)
2007
National public
30
(0.4)
70
(0.4)
22
(0.3)
1
(0.1)
9
(0.2)
91
(0.2)
53
(0.4)
9
(0.2)
17
(2.9)
83
(2.9)
44
(4.5)
8
(1.7)
2007
Large city
36
(0.8)
64
(0.8)
19
(0.6)
2
(0.1)
13
(0.8)
87
(0.8)
50
(1.4)
9
(0.9)
21
(6.6)
79
(6.6)
32
(10.3)
3
(†)
2007
Atlanta
48
(1.7)
52
(1.7)
10
(1.3)
#
(†)
8
(2.3)
92
(2.3)
57
(4.3)
14
(2.9)
‡
(†)
‡
(†)
‡
(†)
‡
(†)
2007
Austin
26
(1.5)
74
(1.5)
22
(1.6)
1
(0.5)
4
(1.0)
96
(1.0)
69
(2.6)
15
(1.5)
‡
(†)
‡
(†)
‡
(†)
‡
(†)
2007
Baltimore City
—
(†)
—
(†)
—
(†)
—
(†)
—
(†)
—
(†)
—
(†)
—
(†)
—
(†)
—
(†)
—
(†)
—
(†)
2007
Boston
25
(1.5)
75
(1.5)
24
(1.8)
3
(0.8)
14
(3.1)
86
(3.1)
43
(4.7)
7
(2.4)
‡
(†)
‡
(†)
‡
(†)
‡
(†)
2007
Charlotte
23
(2.3)
77
(2.3)
23
(1.7)
1
(0.4)
6
(1.2)
94
(1.2)
64
(2.3)
14
(2.0)
‡
(†)
‡
(†)
‡
(†)
‡
(†)
2007
Chicago
46
(1.6)
54
(1.6)
12
(0.9)
1
(0.2)
22
(3.1)
78
(3.1)
42
(3.9)
7
(2.6)
‡
(†)
‡
(†)
‡
(†)
‡
(†)
2007
Cleveland
47
(2.4)
53
(2.4)
10
(1.7)
#
(0.2)
‡
(†)
‡
(†)
‡
(†)
‡
(†)
‡
(†)
‡
(†)
‡
(†)
‡
(†)
2007
Detroit
—
(†)
—
(†)
—
(†)
—
(†)
—
(†)
—
(†)
—
(†)
—
(†)
—
(†)
—
(†)
—
(†)
—
(†)
2007
District of Columbia (DCPS)
57
(1.7)
43
(1.7)
7
(0.7)
#
(0.2)
36
(2.2)
64
(2.2)
27
(1.7)
7
(1.1)
‡
(†)
‡
(†)
‡
(†)
‡
(†)
2007
Fresno
—
(†)
—
(†)
—
(†)
—
(†)
—
(†)
—
(†)
—
(†)
—
(†)
—
(†)
—
(†)
—
(†)
—
(†)
2007
Houston
23
(1.7)
77
(1.7)
22
(1.2)
1
(0.3)
7
(2.3)
93
(2.3)
57
(3.8)
13
(3.1)
‡
(†)
‡
(†)
‡
(†)
‡
(†)
2007
Jefferson County (KY)
—
(†)
—
(†)
—
(†)
—
(†)
—
(†)
—
(†)
—
(†)
—
(†)
—
(†)
—
(†)
—
(†)
—
(†)
2007
Los Angeles
45
(2.0)
55
(2.0)
15
(1.2)
1
(0.3)
24
(2.3)
76
(2.3)
35
(2.6)
5
(0.9)
‡
(†)
‡
(†)
‡
(†)
‡
(†)
2007
Miami-Dade
—
(†)
—
(†)
—
(†)
—
(†)
—
(†)
—
(†)
—
(†)
—
(†)
—
(†)
—
(†)
—
(†)
—
(†)
2007
Milwaukee
—
(†)
—
(†)
—
(†)
—
(†)
—
(†)
—
(†)
—
(†)
—
(†)
—
(†)
—
(†)
—
(†)
—
(†)
2007
New York City
23
(1.8)
77
(1.8)
31
(2.1)
4
(0.7)
8
(2.0)
92
(2.0)
56
(3.1)
8
(3.6)
‡
(†)
‡
(†)
‡
(†)
‡
(†)
2007
Philadelphia
—
(†)
—
(†)
—
(†)
—
(†)
—
(†)
—
(†)
—
(†)
—
(†)
—
(†)
—
(†)
—
(†)
—
(†)
2007
San Diego
35
(2.1)
65
(2.1)
22
(1.7)
2
(0.6)
9
(2.0)
91
(2.0)
57
(3.3)
11
(1.8)
‡
(†)
‡
(†)
‡
(†)
‡
(†)
2005
National public
33
(0.3)
67
(0.3)
19
(0.3)
1
(0.1)
10
(0.2)
90
(0.2)
50
(0.3)
8
(0.2)
21
(1.8)
79
(1.8)
36
(2.2)
5
(0.9)
2005
Large city
40
(0.6)
60
(0.6)
15
(0.4)
1
(0.1)
14
(0.7)
86
(0.7)
47
(1.2)
9
(0.6)
32
(4.0)
68
(4.0)
27
(3.7)
3
(2.1)
2005
Atlanta
52
(2.1)
48
(2.1)
6
(0.8)
#
(†)
16
(2.3)
84
(2.3)
49
(3.1)
13
(3.3)
‡
(†)
‡
(†)
‡
(†)
‡
(†)
2005
Austin
23
(2.2)
77
(2.2)
23
(1.6)
1
(0.6)
2
(1.0)
98
(1.0)
70
(3.2)
16
(2.8)
‡
(†)
‡
(†)
‡
(†)
‡
(†)
2005
Baltimore City
—
(†)
—
(†)
—
(†)
—
(†)
—
(†)
—
(†)
—
(†)
—
(†)
—
(†)
—
(†)
—
(†)
—
(†)
2005
Boston
29
(1.4)
71
(1.4)
19
(1.2)
1
(0.4)
14
(3.0)
86
(3.0)
45
(3.7)
8
(2.9)
‡
(†)
‡
(†)
‡
(†)
‡
(†)
2005
Charlotte
25
(2.5)
75
(2.5)
20
(2.2)
1
(0.3)
6
(1.1)
94
(1.1)
63
(3.2)
16
(1.4)
‡
(†)
‡
(†)
‡
(†)
‡
(†)
2005
Chicago
52
(2.0)
48
(2.0)
9
(1.4)
1
(0.2)
22
(4.1)
78
(4.1)
40
(5.1)
5
(2.4)
‡
(†)
‡
(†)
‡
(†)
‡
(†)
2005
Cleveland
39
(2.3)
61
(2.3)
13
(1.3)
#
(0.2)
‡
(†)
‡
(†)
‡
(†)
‡
(†)
‡
(†)
‡
(†)
‡
(†)
‡
(†)
2005
Detroit
—
(†)
—
(†)
—
(†)
—
(†)
—
(†)
—
(†)
—
(†)
—
(†)
—
(†)
—
(†)
—
(†)
—
(†)
2005
District of Columbia (DCPS)
62
(1.3)
38
(1.3)
5
(0.7)
#
(†)
32
(2.1)
68
(2.1)
27
(2.4)
5
(1.4)
‡
(†)
‡
(†)
‡
(†)
‡
(†)
2005
Fresno
—
(†)
—
(†)
—
(†)
—
(†)
—
(†)
—
(†)
—
(†)
—
(†)
—
(†)
—
(†)
—
(†)
—
(†)
2005
Houston
27
(1.7)
73
(1.7)
18
(1.7)
1
(0.2)
9
(1.7)
91
(1.7)
55
(4.4)
11
(2.0)
‡
(†)
‡
(†)
‡
(†)
‡
(†)
2005
Jefferson County (KY)
—
(†)
—
(†)
—
(†)
—
(†)
—
(†)
—
(†)
—
(†)
—
(†)
—
(†)
—
(†)
—
(†)
—
(†)
2005
Los Angeles
47
(1.7)
53
(1.7)
13
(1.1)
1
(0.3)
12
(2.7)
88
(2.7)
51
(3.4)
11
(3.1)
‡
(†)
‡
(†)
‡
(†)
‡
(†)
2005
Miami-Dade
—
(†)
—
(†)
—
(†)
—
(†)
—
(†)
—
(†)
—
(†)
—
(†)
—
(†)
—
(†)
—
(†)
—
(†)
2005
Milwaukee
—
(†)
—
(†)
—
(†)
—
(†)
—
(†)
—
(†)
—
(†)
—
(†)
—
(†)
—
(†)
—
(†)
—
(†)
2005
New York City
30
(1.8)
70
(1.8)
22
(1.6)
2
(0.5)
13
(2.5)
87
(2.5)
42
(4.5)
7
(2.3)
‡
(†)
‡
(†)
‡
(†)
‡
(†)
2005
Philadelphia
—
(†)
—
(†)
—
(†)
—
(†)
—
(†)
—
(†)
—
(†)
—
(†)
—
(†)
—
(†)
—
(†)
—
(†)
2005
San Diego
34
(1.5)
66
(1.5)
19
(1.8)
2
(0.6)
11
(1.9)
89
(1.9)
47
(3.2)
8
(1.8)
‡
(†)
‡
(†)
‡
(†)
‡
(†)
2003
National public
38
(0.5)
62
(0.5)
15
(0.3)
1
(0.1)
12
(0.3)
88
(0.3)
45
(0.5)
6
(0.2)
23
(1.9)
77
(1.9)
34
(1.9)
4
(0.5)
2003
Large city
45
(1.0)
55
(1.0)
12
(0.6)
1
(0.1)
19
(1.6)
81
(1.6)
40
(2.5)
7
(1.1)
26
(2.8)
74
(2.8)
30
(3.2)
3
(0.6)
2003
Atlanta
57
(2.1)
43
(2.1)
5
(0.8)
#
(†)
21
(6.3)
79
(6.3)
50
(8.0)
11
(3.1)
‡
(†)
‡
(†)
‡
(†)
‡
(†)
2003
Austin
—
(†)
—
(†)
—
(†)
—
(†)
—
(†)
—
(†)
—
(†)
—
(†)
—
(†)
—
(†)
—
(†)
—
(†)
2003
Baltimore City
—
(†)
—
(†)
—
(†)
—
(†)
—
(†)
—
(†)
—
(†)
—
(†)
—
(†)
—
(†)
—
(†)
—
(†)
2003
Boston
43
(2.2)
57
(2.2)
10
(1.3)
1
(0.3)
24
(4.7)
76
(4.7)
31
(5.6)
3
(†)
42
(7.1)
58
(7.1)
14
(4.4)
2
(†)
2003
Charlotte
26
(2.0)
74
(2.0)
19
(2.1)
2
(0.5)
8
(1.8)
92
(1.8)
59
(2.5)
10
(1.8)
‡
(†)
‡
(†)
‡
(†)
‡
(†)
2003
Chicago
53
(2.1)
47
(2.1)
8
(0.9)
#
(0.1)
28
(5.1)
72
(5.1)
24
(5.1)
2
(1.7)
31
(5.3)
69
(5.3)
20
(4.8)
3
(1.2)
2003
Cleveland
49
(2.1)
51
(2.1)
10
(1.4)
#
(0.2)
‡
(†)
‡
(†)
‡
(†)
‡
(†)
‡
(†)
‡
(†)
‡
(†)
‡
(†)
2003
Detroit
—
(†)
—
(†)
—
(†)
—
(†)
—
(†)
—
(†)
—
(†)
—
(†)
—
(†)
—
(†)
—
(†)
—
(†)
2003
District of Columbia (DCPS)
71
(1.2)
29
(1.2)
3
(0.4)
#
(†)
43
(2.6)
57
(2.6)
20
(1.9)
4
(0.8)
61
(4.9)
39
(4.9)
7
(2.7)
#
(†)
2003
Fresno
—
(†)
—
(†)
—
(†)
—
(†)
—
(†)
—
(†)
—
(†)
—
(†)
—
(†)
—
(†)
—
(†)
—
(†)
2003
Houston
34
(2.5)
66
(2.5)
13
(1.6)
1
(0.3)
18
(3.7)
82
(3.7)
37
(5.2)
4
(1.8)
‡
(†)
‡
(†)
‡
(†)
‡
(†)
2003
Jefferson County (KY)
—
(†)
—
(†)
—
(†)
—
(†)
—
(†)
—
(†)
—
(†)
—
(†)
—
(†)
—
(†)
—
(†)
—
(†)
2003
Los Angeles
53
(1.5)
47
(1.5)
8
(0.8)
#
(0.2)
30
(5.0)
70
(5.0)
25
(6.1)
2
(†)
20
(2.5)
80
(2.5)
41
(3.8)
4
(1.0)
2003
Miami-Dade
—
(†)
—
(†)
—
(†)
—
(†)
—
(†)
—
(†)
—
(†)
—
(†)
—
(†)
—
(†)
—
(†)
—
(†)
2003
Milwaukee
—
(†)
—
(†)
—
(†)
—
(†)
—
(†)
—
(†)
—
(†)
—
(†)
—
(†)
—
(†)
—
(†)
—
(†)
2003
New York City
36
(2.0)
64
(2.0)
18
(1.5)
2
(0.5)
11
(2.4)
89
(2.4)
49
(4.6)
9
(3.6)
11
(5.8)
89
(5.8)
41
(9.4)
5
(1.6)
2003
Philadelphia
—
(†)
—
(†)
—
(†)
—
(†)
—
(†)
—
(†)
—
(†)
—
(†)
—
(†)
—
(†)
—
(†)
—
(†)
2003
San Diego
44
(2.1)
56
(2.1)
10
(1.2)
#
(†)
18
(3.0)
82
(3.0)
35
(3.6)
5
(1.4)
20
(7.1)
80
(7.1)
30
(6.6)
4
(3.0)