Percentages at or above each achievement level for grade 4 mathematics, by status as English learner, 2 categories and jurisdiction: 2009, 2007, 2005, and 2003
YearJurisdictionELLNot ELL
below BasicStandard Errorat or above BasicStandard Errorat or above ProficientStandard Errorat AdvancedStandard Errorbelow BasicStandard Errorat or above BasicStandard Errorat or above ProficientStandard Errorat AdvancedStandard Error
— Not available.
† Not applicable.
# Rounds to zero.
‡ Reporting standards not met.
NOTE: DCPS = District of Columbia Public Schools. Detail may not sum to totals because of rounding. Some apparent differences between estimates may not be statistically significant. Analyze results with NAEP Data Explorer.
SOURCE: U.S. Department of Education, Institute of Education Sciences, National Center for Education Statistics, National Assessment of Educational Progress (NAEP), 2003, 2005, 2007, and 2009 Mathematics Assessments.
2009National public43(0.9)57(0.9)12(0.6)1(0.1)16(0.2)84(0.2)41(0.3)6(0.2)
2009 Large city45(1.4)55(1.4)11(1.0)#(0.1)24(0.5)76(0.5)33(0.8)6(0.4)
2009 Atlanta‡(†)‡(†)‡(†)‡(†)36(1.8)64(1.8)22(1.0)4(0.6)
2009 Austin26(2.3)74(2.3)20(1.9)1(0.5)12(2.0)88(2.0)46(1.7)8(1.2)
2009 Baltimore City‡(†)‡(†)‡(†)‡(†)36(1.9)64(1.9)13(1.2)1(0.3)
2009 Boston35(3.4)65(3.4)13(3.1)1(†)16(1.5)84(1.5)34(2.0)5(0.8)
2009 Charlotte25(4.7)75(4.7)17(4.0)1(†)13(1.3)87(1.3)47(2.1)11(1.3)
2009 Chicago56(4.9)44(4.9)7(2.2)1(†)36(1.7)64(1.7)19(1.5)2(0.5)
2009 Cleveland‡(†)‡(†)‡(†)‡(†)49(2.2)51(2.2)9(1.3)#(0.3)
2009 Detroit‡(†)‡(†)‡(†)‡(†)69(2.5)31(2.5)3(1.0)#(†)
2009 District of Columbia (DCPS)44(5.9)56(5.9)15(4.2)1(†)43(1.5)57(1.5)19(0.9)4(0.5)
2009 Fresno59(3.6)41(3.6)3(1.2)#(†)35(2.3)65(2.3)19(1.8)1(0.6)
2009 Houston22(2.1)78(2.1)22(2.4)1(0.3)16(2.2)84(2.2)35(2.5)4(0.8)
2009 Jefferson County (KY)‡(†)‡(†)‡(†)‡(†)27(1.8)73(1.8)32(2.2)6(1.0)
2009 Los Angeles60(2.4)40(2.4)4(1.3)#(†)24(1.4)76(1.4)29(2.6)3(0.8)
2009 Miami-Dade45(3.5)55(3.5)13(3.0)1(†)17(1.7)83(1.7)34(2.0)4(0.6)
2009 Milwaukee33(4.8)67(4.8)15(3.0)1(†)42(2.7)58(2.7)15(1.9)1(0.4)
2009 New York City41(3.5)59(3.5)13(2.1)#(†)17(1.2)83(1.2)39(2.0)7(0.8)
2009 Philadelphia57(5.4)43(5.4)10(3.3)1(†)38(2.0)62(2.0)17(1.7)2(0.6)
2009 San Diego43(2.9)57(2.9)13(1.7)#(†)11(1.7)89(1.7)49(2.9)10(1.4)
2007National public44(0.7)56(0.7)13(0.5)1(0.1)16(0.2)84(0.2)42(0.3)6(0.1)
2007 Large city48(1.2)52(1.2)12(1.1)1(0.2)25(0.7)75(0.7)32(0.8)5(0.4)
2007 Atlanta‡(†)‡(†)‡(†)‡(†)38(1.5)62(1.5)21(1.5)3(0.7)
2007 Austin30(2.6)70(2.6)17(2.0)1(0.4)13(0.9)87(0.9)49(2.7)9(0.8)
2007 Baltimore City—(†)—(†)—(†)—(†)—(†)—(†)—(†)—(†)
2007 Boston30(2.7)70(2.7)23(3.3)2(0.9)20(1.8)80(1.8)29(2.5)4(0.9)
2007 Charlotte23(4.3)77(4.3)21(4.3)1(†)14(1.6)86(1.6)47(1.8)9(1.2)
2007 Chicago56(3.3)44(3.3)6(1.2)#(†)39(1.8)61(1.8)19(1.4)2(0.5)
2007 Cleveland59(6.3)41(6.3)6(2.9)#(†)46(2.4)54(2.4)10(1.8)#(0.3)
2007 Detroit—(†)—(†)—(†)—(†)—(†)—(†)—(†)—(†)
2007 District of Columbia (DCPS)58(4.0)42(4.0)9(2.9)1(0.9)50(1.4)50(1.4)14(0.8)3(0.4)
2007 Fresno—(†)—(†)—(†)—(†)—(†)—(†)—(†)—(†)
2007 Houston23(2.6)77(2.6)19(2.1)1(0.3)19(1.6)81(1.6)33(1.7)4(0.8)
2007 Jefferson County (KY)—(†)—(†)—(†)—(†)—(†)—(†)—(†)—(†)
2007 Los Angeles57(2.1)43(2.1)7(1.0)#(0.1)25(1.4)75(1.4)30(1.4)3(0.5)
2007 Miami-Dade—(†)—(†)—(†)—(†)—(†)—(†)—(†)—(†)
2007 Milwaukee—(†)—(†)—(†)—(†)—(†)—(†)—(†)—(†)
2007 New York City44(4.1)56(4.1)11(2.3)1(†)17(1.6)83(1.6)38(1.9)6(1.0)
2007 Philadelphia—(†)—(†)—(†)—(†)—(†)—(†)—(†)—(†)
2007 San Diego42(2.6)58(2.6)15(2.0)1(0.5)15(1.8)85(1.8)48(2.7)8(1.4)
2005National public46(0.8)54(0.8)11(0.4)1(0.1)18(0.2)82(0.2)38(0.3)5(0.1)
2005 Large city50(1.1)50(1.1)10(0.6)#(0.2)28(0.6)72(0.6)28(0.6)4(0.3)
2005 Atlanta‡(†)‡(†)‡(†)‡(†)43(1.6)57(1.6)17(1.0)3(0.8)
2005 Austin32(3.5)68(3.5)14(2.4)1(†)10(1.3)90(1.3)48(2.0)9(1.5)
2005 Baltimore City—(†)—(†)—(†)—(†)—(†)—(†)—(†)—(†)
2005 Boston39(4.5)61(4.5)14(3.0)#(†)26(1.3)74(1.3)23(1.4)2(0.7)
2005 Charlotte24(4.8)76(4.8)16(3.1)2(1.0)14(1.2)86(1.2)47(2.5)10(1.0)
2005 Chicago72(3.4)28(3.4)3(1.1)#(†)44(2.0)56(2.0)15(1.9)1(0.5)
2005 Cleveland‡(†)‡(†)‡(†)‡(†)40(2.3)60(2.3)13(1.3)#(0.2)
2005 Detroit—(†)—(†)—(†)—(†)—(†)—(†)—(†)—(†)
2005 District of Columbia (DCPS)64(5.9)36(5.9)7(2.8)1(†)55(1.2)45(1.2)10(0.8)1(0.4)
2005 Fresno—(†)—(†)—(†)—(†)—(†)—(†)—(†)—(†)
2005 Houston27(2.2)73(2.2)16(2.1)#(†)20(2.2)80(2.2)32(2.8)4(0.9)
2005 Jefferson County (KY)—(†)—(†)—(†)—(†)—(†)—(†)—(†)—(†)
2005 Los Angeles55(1.9)45(1.9)8(1.0)#(†)28(1.9)72(1.9)30(2.1)4(1.2)
2005 Miami-Dade—(†)—(†)—(†)—(†)—(†)—(†)—(†)—(†)
2005 Milwaukee—(†)—(†)—(†)—(†)—(†)—(†)—(†)—(†)
2005 New York City52(4.9)48(4.9)5(2.2)#(†)24(1.7)76(1.7)28(1.7)3(0.7)
2005 Philadelphia—(†)—(†)—(†)—(†)—(†)—(†)—(†)—(†)
2005 San Diego45(1.8)55(1.8)11(2.2)1(0.4)16(2.4)84(2.4)39(2.4)6(1.2)
2003National public51(1.1)49(1.1)9(0.6)#(0.1)21(0.3)79(0.3)34(0.3)4(0.1)
2003 Large city55(1.9)45(1.9)7(0.7)#(0.1)33(1.0)67(1.0)24(1.1)3(0.4)
2003 Atlanta‡(†)‡(†)‡(†)‡(†)50(2.0)50(2.0)13(1.6)2(0.6)
2003 Austin—(†)—(†)—(†)—(†)—(†)—(†)—(†)—(†)
2003 Baltimore City—(†)—(†)—(†)—(†)—(†)—(†)—(†)—(†)
2003 Boston59(5.3)41(5.3)5(1.5)#(†)38(2.5)62(2.5)14(1.8)1(0.5)
2003 Charlotte33(4.4)67(4.4)17(5.5)2(†)15(1.6)85(1.6)43(2.2)6(1.1)
2003 Chicago67(4.9)33(4.9)3(1.5)#(†)46(1.9)54(1.9)11(1.2)1(0.3)
2003 Cleveland‡(†)‡(†)‡(†)‡(†)49(2.2)51(2.2)10(1.4)#(0.2)
2003 Detroit—(†)—(†)—(†)—(†)—(†)—(†)—(†)—(†)
2003 District of Columbia (DCPS)72(4.9)28(4.9)3(1.8)#(†)63(1.1)37(1.1)7(0.6)1(0.2)
2003 Fresno—(†)—(†)—(†)—(†)—(†)—(†)—(†)—(†)
2003 Houston39(3.4)61(3.4)10(1.9)#(†)26(2.7)74(2.7)22(2.9)2(0.7)
2003 Jefferson County (KY)—(†)—(†)—(†)—(†)—(†)—(†)—(†)—(†)
2003 Los Angeles61(1.5)39(1.5)4(0.7)#(†)32(2.3)68(2.3)23(2.3)2(0.4)
2003 Miami-Dade—(†)—(†)—(†)—(†)—(†)—(†)—(†)—(†)
2003 Milwaukee—(†)—(†)—(†)—(†)—(†)—(†)—(†)—(†)
2003 New York City66(6.1)34(6.1)7(2.0)#(†)30(1.8)70(1.8)22(1.4)3(0.5)
2003 Philadelphia—(†)—(†)—(†)—(†)—(†)—(†)—(†)—(†)
2003 San Diego55(2.8)45(2.8)5(1.2)#(†)23(1.8)77(1.8)27(2.5)3(1.0)